Vanilla extract is a staple in nearly every kitchenβbut not all extracts are created equal. If youβve only ever used store-bought extract, you're missing out on the rich, nuanced flavor of homemade vanilla. Whether you're baking cookies, cakes, or custards, homemade vanilla extract adds depth and authenticity that elevates your recipes to the next level.
Why Homemade Vanilla Extract Tastes Better
Mass-produced vanilla extract often includes additives, coloring, and less-than-premium vanilla beans. By making your own, you control every aspect of the process: the bean origin, the alcohol used, and how long it steeps. Over time, the result is a rich, aromatic extract thatβs as unique as the person who made itβyou!
Some reasons homemade extract wins in baking:
-
β Itβs free of artificial sweeteners and additives.
-
β You can use premium beans like Ugandan or Mexican for bolder flavors.
-
β Itβs more cost-effective in the long runβone batch can last a year or more.
Best Vanilla Beans for Baking
Some vanilla beans naturally complement baked goods better than others. Here are a few top picks from our collection of 50+ vanilla beans, cacao, and cinnamon blends:
-
Mexican Vanilla Beans β Bold, dark, and creamyβperfect for chocolate chip cookies and brownies.
-
Ugandan Vanilla Beans β Rich, earthy, and subtly smoky, great for spice cakes and pound cakes.
-
Tahitian Vanilla Beans β Floral and light, ideal for custards, cream-based desserts, and meringues.
Want help picking the perfect vanilla bean? Take our Vanilla Extract Quiz to find the bean and spirit combo that fits your style.
Baking with Vanilla Extract: Tips for Success
π§ Add it at the right time: Stir your extract into the batter or dough early so it incorporates evenly and fully infuses your recipe.
π‘ Bake with patience: The flavors of homemade extract deepen as they bakeβdonβt rush it.
π Use quality, not quantity: Just 1β2 tsp of homemade extract often delivers stronger flavor than a tablespoon of imitation.
Bonus Tip: Bake with Vanilla-Cacao or Vanilla-Cinnamon Blends
Our cacao- and cinnamon-infused vanilla bean blends add extra complexity to your baked goods. Try cacao for chocolate-based recipes, or cinnamon for cozy fall bakes like pumpkin bread or snickerdoodles.
