Sweet Heart's Cherry Cheesecake

Posted by on

Ok. Here’s a throwback recipe I’ve had for years! You know that cookbook that just shows up in your college apartment and you’re not sure who’s it is? It may have even been there from the girls before.  I still have it:)

I used this cheesecake recipe for a Valentine’s dinner for my then college boyfriend, now hubby for over 20 years!  

 Since then we've enjoyed many Valentine's dates. Some romantic,  Some with our boys and chocolate treasure hunts. 

But that very first Valentines Day, I remember, mostly because of the company, and partly because of the cheesecake. Who doesn’t love cheesecake?! 

 Truthfully there isn’t anything fancy or unique about this cheesecake. It’s just a good fool proof recipe you can count on. But what I’ve learned through the years of baking is this…. quality vanilla can transfer your confections from good to great! Tongan rum with it’s cherry undertones is the perfect companion to these cherries.  If you’re in hurry, by all means, use the canned cherry pie filling at the grocery store.  Although, if you want to make your own sweet cherries, go to our previous post cherry hand pies. Either way don’t forget that yummy vanilla!




1/3 cups crushed chocolate wafer cookies or vanilla wafers

1/4 cup melted butter

2 tablespoons sugar


4 Large eggs

½ cup butter softened

2 (8-ounce) packages cream cheese, softened

1 cup sugar

1 tablespoon cornstarch

1 teaspoon baking powder

1 tablespoon lemon juice


1 cup sour cream

2 tablespoons sugar

1 teaspoon Vanillapura Madagascar/vodka vanilla extract


-1 (21-ounce) can cherry pie filling

1 tsp of Vanillapura Tongan/rum vanilla extract

-3 tablespoons kirsch or orange juice, if desired

- Or make your own cherry hand pies



  1. STEP 1

Heat oven to 325°F. Wrap outside of 9-inch spring form pan with aluminum foil. Lightly grease inside of pan. 

  1. STEP 2

Combine all crust ingredients in bowl. Press onto bottom of prepared pan. Bake 10 minutes. Cool.

  1. STEP 3

Place egg whites into bowl. Beat at high speed, scraping bowl often, until soft peaks form. Set aside.

  1. STEP 4

Combine 1/2 cup butter, cream cheese and egg yolks into bowl. Beat at medium speed, scraping bowl often, until creamy. Add all remaining filling ingredients except egg whites. Continue beating, scraping bowl often, until well mixed. Gently stir in beaten egg whites.

  1. STEP 5

Spoon filling into crust. Place cheesecake onto center rack of oven. Place pan of warm water on rack below cheesecake to prevent cracking. Bake 55-65 minutes or until center is set and firm to the touch. Cool 15 minutes.

  1. STEP 6

Loosen sides of cheesecake from pan by running knife around inside of pan. Cool completely. (Cheesecake center will dip slightly upon cooling.)

  1. STEP 7

Combine sour cream, 2 tablespoons sugar and vanilla in bowl; mix well. Spread evenly over top of cheesecake. Spoon out 2 to 3 tablespoons cherry sauce from pie filling; drop by teaspoonful onto sour cream topping. Carefully pull knife or spatula through cherry sauce to form hearts. Cover; refrigerate at least 4 hours.

  1. STEP 8

Stir together remaining pie filling and kirsch in bowl; spoon over cheesecake at serving time.  Don’t forget to add the vanilla. Store refrigerated.

A big thank you to Land O Lakes for this long time favorite recipe.



cheesecake cherry desserts Madagascar/vodka extract madagascar/vodka extract tongan tongan vanilla extract

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published


appetizers apple desserts apple pie aromatic aromatic sweets autumn desserts Bailey's Irish cream baking banana banana bread BBQ black berries blackberries blackberry compote Blueberries blueberrries blueberry tart breakfast brie Brownies brunch candies pecans cannoli caramel cheescake cheese cheesecake cherry desserts cherry ice cream cherry pie chocolate chocolate cake chocolate chip cookies chocolate chips chocolate crepe chocolate mousse chocolate topping christmas cookies Christmas food and drink christmas gifts christmas party christmas snacks christmas traditions cinnamon cinnamon rolls citrus coconut coconut cake coffee creamer cold winter days cookedeggnog cookie crust cookie dough cookies cream crepes crock pot dark chocolate dessert dessert table desserts dip it donuts double chocolate easter brunch eggnog extract flan french toast frosting fruit tart Fruity german pancakes gingerbread glazed donuts halloween halloween desserts halloween party Holiday desserts holidays hot chocolate hygge ice cream ice cream topping indonesian vanilla indonesian vanilla extract Indonesian/rum extract lemon lemon bars lemon curd lemon desserts lemon meringue lemons madagascar rum extract madagascar vanilla beans madagascar vanilla extract madagascar/rum vanilla extract Madagascar/vodka extract madagascar/vodka extract tongan Mexican rum vanilla extract mexican vanilla Mexican vanilla beans mexican vanilla extract muffin muffins neighbor gifts no churn ice cream pancakes party favor party food peanut butter peanut butter blossoms peanut butter cookies Picnics Pie pie crust pumpkin pumpkin donuts Pumpkin pie pure vanilla extract raspberries raspberry tart salmon salmon glaze sauce slow cooker slow cooking spanish flan St Patrick's Day Strawberries strawberry sugar cookies sweets syrup S’mores tahitian vanilla extract tart Thanksgiving thanksgiving desserts Tongan Rum extract tongan vanilla extract tongan/rum vanilla extract trifles Valentine's Day dessert vanilla vanilla bean paste vanilla beans vanilla extract vanilla ice cream vanilla syrup vanillapura