Introduction
Vanilla extract may seem simple—just beans and alcohol—but its flavor is anything but. One of the most common questions from extract makers is: How long should I let it sit before using it? The answer is rooted in patience, science, and your flavor goals.
⏳ Minimum Time: 8 Weeks (But That’s Just the Start)
The absolute minimum time for your extract to develop any meaningful vanilla flavor is 8 weeks. We don't recommend waiting only 8 weeks, but we have many extract-making friends that say, "I used mine at 8 weeks and loved it." and who are we to say they didn't? At the 8-week stage, you'll notice a light aroma and taste, but it will be nowhere near the complexity of a mature extract. If you're baking something mild like sugar cookies, this may suffice—but it’s not ideal for full-bodied flavor, in our experience.
🍷 The Sweet Spot: 12 Months
To achieve a rich, deep, well-rounded vanilla flavor, most extract makers recommend aging your vanilla extract for at least 12 months being the gold standard.
Why 12 Months?
-
Full extraction of over 300 flavor compounds.
-
Alcohol has time to mellow and integrate with the vanilla.
-
Aroma becomes significantly stronger.
-
Color deepens to a rich, amber hue.
This longer steeping time is especially important for double-fold extracts, which use more beans and deliver more concentrated flavor.
🥄 Stirring and Shaking: Does It Help?
Yes! Gently shaking your bottle once a week encourages alcohol circulation, which extracts flavor from the beans more evenly. Just make sure the beans are always fully submerged to ensure that each part of the bean is being extracted.
❄️ Storage Matters
To ensure your extract ages properly:
-
Keep it in a dark, cool place like a pantry or cupboard.
-
Avoid refrigeration, as it can cause condensation.
-
Use a glass bottle with a tight seal.
🧪 How to Tell When It’s Ready
There’s no single "finish line" for extract readiness. But here are signs it’s ready:
-
Smells richly of vanilla, not alcohol.
-
Color is dark brown or amber.
-
No more “sharp” alcohol bite when smelled or tasted.
Taste testing requires a medium like milk or cream to diffuse the concentration and allow for true tasting. Put a couple of drops of extract into a tablespoon of milk or cream, stir, wait a minute and then take a sip. Do you like the taste? If so, start using it. If not, let it sit another month or two and taste test again.
🕰️ Can You Let It Sit Too Long?
Nope! Vanilla extract only gets better with age—just like a fine wine. As long as the beans remain submerged and the bottle is sealed, your extract will continue to evolve for years.
👩🍳 Final Tip: Make a Batch Every Few Months
To always have extract at its peak, start a new bottle every 3–4 months. That way, you’ll have a rotation of vanilla in different stages of aging—so you're never without.
Conclusion
Great vanilla extract can’t be rushed. Letting it steep for months—or even a year—yields a flavor that’s rich, robust, and worthy of your best recipes. So take your time, give it love, and your vanilla will thank you in every drop.
