Here's another extract recipe from one of our favorite extract-making pros, Dawn N. Shared here in her words:
I call this my Vanilla Holiday Extract because I use it in everything from Halloween to New Year's Eve. It pairs well with both sweet and savory dishes that use pumpkins, apples, squash, cranberries, pomegranates, persimmons, quince, figs, or bananas. Add 1T to a large pot of black tea for Holiday Tea or put a dash into a Hot Toddy to spice it up!
.
Ingredients
1 oz vanilla beans (100%Madagascar is great but 50/50 with Mexican is even better as it adds that hint of caramel)
1 cinnamon stick (Ceylon is preferred if you can get it but Cassia works as well)
1 nutmeg (smashed into pieces-4 or more, 7 is a lucky number!)
1-2 allspice berries (depending on size-if large use 1, if small use 2)
12 oz Sailor Jerry's Spiced Rum
.
Sailor Jerry's already has notes of vanilla and oak with hints of clove/cinnamon making it the perfect base for a vanilla holiday extract.
.
How To
Cut the vanilla beans open from top to bottom
Pop the vanilla beans in whole or cut in half if you don't think the alcohol will cover
Break the cinnamon stick in half as needed
Smash up 1 whole nutmeg into at least 4 pieces, lucky 7 is a good number!
Toss in allspice berries
Store in a cool dark place but one you go into frequently so you will see it and remember to shake it up, shake it up. ;)
Check in on it after 6 weeks to see how it is progressing and make decisions from there.
I age mine for a year so the vanilla and spices all deepen but this is 100% personal choice.
.
When is it Ready?
.
Due to the spices and individual taste preference you should smell and taste when this is ready for you. Say for example after 2 months you think the cinnamon is showing up nicely but you can't taste the other spices yet, go ahead and remove the cinnamon and leave the nutmeg and allspice in longer.
.
You can also play around with all 3 spice levels, switch out the rum, add a clove = let this be a base recipe you jump from to create your own custom blend.
Here's a video tutorial of a holiday extract very similar to this one:
I have this brewing since March. I probably added too much of all the ingredients but this stuff is killer great! I did some taste tests in cream with friends and they wanted to guzzle it. I am going to make another batch today so I never run out. Could use it as a holiday drink according to my friends 😝
— Terry
I have this brewing since March. I probably added too much of all the ingredients but this stuff is killer great! I did some taste tests in cream with friends and they wanted to guzzle it. I am going to make another batch today so I never run out. Could use it as a holiday drink according to my friends 😝
— Terry
O yum I’m making some of this awesomeness!! Thank you Jeff
— KElly
This is a great-soubfing recipe!! Thank you!!
— Lori
How long can you use your vanilla Bean that is soaking in the Rum
I had a gift vanilla bean. Just one but it was a long one. I made extract and it was great. I bought what was supposed to be 2 vanilla beans but there was only 1 skinny bean. 4 oz of moist, fragrant beans looks like the was to go. Now time will tell when my extract is finished.
Janet Wood
09/18/2026
Sold out 😭
So sad these are sold out! I heard about these online and everyone must have too, so they must be amazing! Hopefully these will restock and I can get a chance to order and try! I have signed up for notifications.
Kat
09/13/2026
Love them
I just love these beautiful beans. If you haven't tried them you need to.
Sharon Molnar
09/12/2026
Gorgeous beans!
Gorgeous beans! The black magic blend never disappoints. They are plump and oily and smell amazing. Can’t wait for the extract to be ready!
Michelle Rosa
09/11/2026
I love the Madagascar beans. So oily, plump and smells so yummy 😋
I love the Madagascar beans. So oily
Sharon Molnar
09/11/2026
Patience is supposed to be a virtue?
The Madagascar beans are swimming in Reign Cane vodka. Now for the waiting!
Anonymous
09/06/2026
Gorgeous giant beans!
Gorgeous giant beans! Pompona pack is one of my faves!
Michelle Rosa
09/03/2026
Aroma is wonderful
I can't wait for this to finish exiting. I will be great for next summer baking.
Sharon Molnar
09/03/2026
These beams were top
These beams were top notch!
Dee George
09/02/2026
So incredibly nice!
I've purchased several extract bottles from VanillaPura. However, the Rimatara bottles are one of my top two favorites! I love the simplicity of the bottle shape, the synthetic cork stopper, and that it's really heavy duty. Just an amazing bottle!
Lori
08/31/2026
Great Quality
I was so impressed with these beans. They are perfect for my vanilla extract. I must give props to customer service because they quickly corrected a mistake I had made. This is the first time I’ve done business with VanillaPura and I’m very happy.
Saundra Lemaster
08/30/2026
The oil in these was superb
The oil in these was superb. I see a lot of vanilla beans come to me that are dry grade A beans, but these were completely oily. That’s a wonderful thing.
Disappointed
08/30/2026
Got two of the 8.5 ounce. They are nice and heavy and beautiful. The cap fits very snuggly and they stack well in the cabinet. I would love to order a case but a bit too pricey for my budget.
Christie
08/29/2026
It smelled amazing!! I cannot wait for the extract to be ready next year.
Comments
I have this brewing since March. I probably added too much of all the ingredients but this stuff is killer great! I did some taste tests in cream with friends and they wanted to guzzle it. I am going to make another batch today so I never run out. Could use it as a holiday drink according to my friends 😝
I have this brewing since March. I probably added too much of all the ingredients but this stuff is killer great! I did some taste tests in cream with friends and they wanted to guzzle it. I am going to make another batch today so I never run out. Could use it as a holiday drink according to my friends 😝
O yum I’m making some of this awesomeness!! Thank you Jeff
This is a great-soubfing recipe!! Thank you!!
How long can you use your vanilla Bean that is soaking in the Rum